If a criminal figures out a more effective way to break into people’s homes to steal more, should he receive a lighter sentence per dollar of what he steals? Biden’s nominee for the U.S. Supreme Court, Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson, certainly thinks so.
The legal system doesn’t normally work that way. If a rapist rapes two women, he gets two sentences, one for each crime. Each crime a criminal gets convicted for gets a separate penalty. That has traditionally been true for child pornography, where more pictures of children mean crimes have been committed.
In testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday, Jackson discussed concerns raised primarily by Senator Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) that she was lenient on people who had child pornography. Hawley pointed out that as a judge, there were seven cases where she gave sentences below what was recommended by the federal sentencing guidelines. As a member of the U.S. Sentencing Commission, she also pushed to lower the penalties for child pornography.
“More serious child pornography offenders were based on the volume, based on the number of photographs that they received in the mail, and that made total sense before when we didn’t have the internet, when we didn’t have the distribution,” Jackson explained. “But the way that the guideline is now structured, based on that set of circumstances, is leading to extreme disparities in the system because it is so easy for people to get volumes of this kind of material now by computers.”
The sentencing guidelines help ensure that two criminals who commit the same crime face the same prison term. Jackson claims that a criminal getting 100 child porn pictures through the mail is less harmful than getting 100 pictures on his computer over the internet. The point of the penalties is to discourage pedophiles from getting more pictures because taking pictures harms children. The greater the demand for those pictures, the more children are harmed.
Indeed, Jackson acknowledged this in her answer: “There is only a market because there are lookers. You are contributing to child sex abuse.” But she doesn’t understand where this answer logically takes her. Whether someone pays for an electronic image of child porn or has a printed copy of that picture, they increase the demand.
She claimed that she viewed the crime of child pornography as “damaging,” as “horrible.” But consistently deviating from the sentencing norm established by the guidelines for child porn doesn’t match Jackson’s words.
ABC News came to Jackson’s defense by using Biden administration talking points to note that Senator Hawley had voted for circuit court nominees who, as district court judges, had sentenced criminals below the guidelines for child porn cases. But there is a problem with this claim. Judges will once in a long while deviate from the sentencing guidelines. Indeed, most judges have probably done it a couple or a few times out of the hundreds of cases that they have heard because there might be unusual circumstances that might auger for either stiffer or more lenient sentencing. Republican judges probably do this much less often than Democrat ones. But going through all the circuit court judges that Hawley has voted for and finding a few cases doesn’t prove what ABC thinks it does.
Trump got 174 district court and 54 circuit court judges confirmed. Of all those judges, “An ABC News review of federal judges appointed and confirmed during the Trump administration found nearly a dozen had handed down below-guideline sentences in cases of defendants viewing, possessing, transporting or distributing child pornography.” Suppose that “nearly a dozen” means eleven judges – that is still just 4.8% of the judges that Trump placed on the bench. Undoubtedly, ABC provides no information on exactly the number of cases that handful of judges sentenced below the guidelines for a broad range of pornography cases. For many of that eleven, it could be just one case each.
What is clear is that Jackson is an outlier. For her to do it seven times truly distinguishes her.
Of course, no one should be surprised by Jackson’s record on sentencing. Jackson was a public defender, and they tend to be very liberal. A very liberal president appointed her. Activist organizations on the left strongly support her.
The irony is that with violent crime soaring and Democrats facing backlash over cutting police funds and left-wing District Attorneys refusing to prosecute violent criminals, Democrats are just now wanting to claim that they are not soft on crime. Yet, while Biden and Democrats say one thing, they nominate and vote for a Supreme Court justice who continues their soft on crime policies.
This article originally appeared in Townhall. The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.
Dr. John R. Lott, Jr. founded the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC). An economist and a world-recognized expert on guns and crime, Lott served the Trump administration as the Senior Advisor for Research and Statistics at the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Policy.
Democrats Nominate a Soft on Crime Person for the Supreme Court
Sponsored
Help Law Enforcement in Their Time of Need!If a criminal figures out a more effective way to break into people’s homes to steal more, should he receive a lighter sentence per dollar of what he steals? Biden’s nominee for the U.S. Supreme Court, Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson, certainly thinks so.
The legal system doesn’t normally work that way. If a rapist rapes two women, he gets two sentences, one for each crime. Each crime a criminal gets convicted for gets a separate penalty. That has traditionally been true for child pornography, where more pictures of children mean crimes have been committed.
In testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday, Jackson discussed concerns raised primarily by Senator Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) that she was lenient on people who had child pornography. Hawley pointed out that as a judge, there were seven cases where she gave sentences below what was recommended by the federal sentencing guidelines. As a member of the U.S. Sentencing Commission, she also pushed to lower the penalties for child pornography.
“More serious child pornography offenders were based on the volume, based on the number of photographs that they received in the mail, and that made total sense before when we didn’t have the internet, when we didn’t have the distribution,” Jackson explained. “But the way that the guideline is now structured, based on that set of circumstances, is leading to extreme disparities in the system because it is so easy for people to get volumes of this kind of material now by computers.”
The sentencing guidelines help ensure that two criminals who commit the same crime face the same prison term. Jackson claims that a criminal getting 100 child porn pictures through the mail is less harmful than getting 100 pictures on his computer over the internet. The point of the penalties is to discourage pedophiles from getting more pictures because taking pictures harms children. The greater the demand for those pictures, the more children are harmed.
Indeed, Jackson acknowledged this in her answer: “There is only a market because there are lookers. You are contributing to child sex abuse.” But she doesn’t understand where this answer logically takes her. Whether someone pays for an electronic image of child porn or has a printed copy of that picture, they increase the demand.
She claimed that she viewed the crime of child pornography as “damaging,” as “horrible.” But consistently deviating from the sentencing norm established by the guidelines for child porn doesn’t match Jackson’s words.
ABC News came to Jackson’s defense by using Biden administration talking points to note that Senator Hawley had voted for circuit court nominees who, as district court judges, had sentenced criminals below the guidelines for child porn cases. But there is a problem with this claim. Judges will once in a long while deviate from the sentencing guidelines. Indeed, most judges have probably done it a couple or a few times out of the hundreds of cases that they have heard because there might be unusual circumstances that might auger for either stiffer or more lenient sentencing. Republican judges probably do this much less often than Democrat ones. But going through all the circuit court judges that Hawley has voted for and finding a few cases doesn’t prove what ABC thinks it does.
Trump got 174 district court and 54 circuit court judges confirmed. Of all those judges, “An ABC News review of federal judges appointed and confirmed during the Trump administration found nearly a dozen had handed down below-guideline sentences in cases of defendants viewing, possessing, transporting or distributing child pornography.” Suppose that “nearly a dozen” means eleven judges – that is still just 4.8% of the judges that Trump placed on the bench. Undoubtedly, ABC provides no information on exactly the number of cases that handful of judges sentenced below the guidelines for a broad range of pornography cases. For many of that eleven, it could be just one case each.
What is clear is that Jackson is an outlier. For her to do it seven times truly distinguishes her.
Of course, no one should be surprised by Jackson’s record on sentencing. Jackson was a public defender, and they tend to be very liberal. A very liberal president appointed her. Activist organizations on the left strongly support her.
The irony is that with violent crime soaring and Democrats facing backlash over cutting police funds and left-wing District Attorneys refusing to prosecute violent criminals, Democrats are just now wanting to claim that they are not soft on crime. Yet, while Biden and Democrats say one thing, they nominate and vote for a Supreme Court justice who continues their soft on crime policies.
This article originally appeared in Townhall. The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.
Sponsored
Help Law Enforcement in Their Time of Need!John Lott
Dr. John R. Lott, Jr. founded the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC). An economist and a world-recognized expert on guns and crime, Lott served the Trump administration as the Senior Advisor for Research and Statistics at the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Policy.
John Lott
Dr. John R. Lott, Jr. founded the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC). An economist and a world-recognized expert on guns and crime, Lott served the Trump administration as the Senior Advisor for Research and Statistics at the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Policy.
Search
follow us
subscribe
TRENDING STORIES
Thanks To Trump v. Slaughter, The President You Elected Can Finally Run The Government You Voted For
Delaware Sen. Chris Coons Recovering After Multi-Vehicle Crash
Multiple Members Of Minnesota Antifa Group Indicted For Violent Conspiracy
‘Citizen Vigilante’ Delivers The Warning Western Governments Desperately Need To Hear
SECURITY
Report: New Russian Recruits Survive Just 20 Minutes
Russian military bloggers and independent analysts are painting a bleak picture of Moscow’s war
Iran-Linked Outlet Says Nuclear Bomb Is The Only Answer
TEHRAN — An Iranian media outlet linked to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps said
US Military Strikes Iranian Missile Storage, Drone Facilities, And Coastal Radar After Attack On Commercial Shipping
The U.S. military launched airstrikes Friday against Iranian missile and drone infrastructure after Tehran
Iran Launches Drone Attack On Bahrain After US Strikes Iranian Military Sites
Iran launched a drone attack against Bahrain early Saturday, opening a new front in
FOREIGN AFFAIRS
Report: New Russian Recruits Survive Just 20 Minutes
Russian military bloggers and independent analysts are painting a bleak picture of Moscow’s war
Iran-Linked Outlet Says Nuclear Bomb Is The Only Answer
TEHRAN — An Iranian media outlet linked to the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps said
Elon Musk Streams Banned German Film After Censorship Fight Over Migration Themes
Elon Musk is once again at the center of the global free speech debate—this
US Military Strikes Iranian Missile Storage, Drone Facilities, And Coastal Radar After Attack On Commercial Shipping
The U.S. military launched airstrikes Friday against Iranian missile and drone infrastructure after Tehran
BUSINESS & ECONOMICS
Trump Alleges Pump Price ‘Gouging,’ Orders DOJ Probe
President Donald Trump has ordered the Department of Justice to investigate major oil companies
Trump’s Surprise Move Throws Bipartisan Housing Deal Into Limbo
WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump abruptly canceled the signing ceremony for a major bipartisan
Former Federal Reserve Chief Alan Greenspan Dead At 100
Alan Greenspan, the influential economist who led the Federal Reserve through nearly two decades
The Awkward Truth Behind Matt Walsh’s Data Center Claim
Imagine a tenant who signs a lease everyone agrees is temporary, then asks the
HEALTH & SCIENCE
Delaware Sen. Chris Coons Recovering After Multi-Vehicle Crash
Delaware Sen. Chris Coons (D) is recovering after being hospitalized with minor injuries following
Janice Dean Says Goodbye To Fox News After 22 Years On Air
NEW YORK — Veteran Fox News meteorologist Janice Dean announced Thursday that she is
Audio Reveals What RFK Jr. Urged An Iowa Libertarian Candidate To Do Behind Closed Doors
He was not the only one from the Hawkeye State… WASHINGTON — Health and
Josh Shapiro Embraces ‘Medical Freedom’ Rhetoric As 2028 Speculation Grows
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro is drawing attention for comments that appeared to echo one
At American Liberty News, we eschew the mainstream media’s tightly controlled narrative to provide our readers with real news, real insights, and the means to take action. We seek out insightful coverage – and partner with knowledgeable and experienced people and organizations to bring you the information and insight our readers demand.
We humbly seek to provide the tools and information necessary for our readers to decide for themselves what is true and what is right.
TOP TAGS
TOP CATEGORIES
FEATURES
American Liberty News ©2024
Evolution Digital Media
1900 Reston Metro Plz
Suite 600
Reston, VA 20190