Eastman Memo Reveals Otherwise Laughable Plan That Would Have Led to Civil War-Level Crisis

Office of Speaker Mike Johnson, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
American Liberty News
- July 21, 2024
0 views 4 min

House Speaker (R-La.) has responded vehemently to President Biden's recent declaration that he will not seek reelection, instead endorsing Vice President to be the Democratic Party's nominee.

Taking to X, Johnson lambasted Biden and the Democratic Party in a series of posts:

Democrats have been complicit in the largest political cover-up in history. They have known for a long while that was not capable of holding his office.

At this stage, it doesn't matter who President Trump runs against..

Everyone on the right end of the political spectrum in command of the facts has a solemn responsibility to call out the outrageous plot to overturn the results of the what it was: incredibly frightening.

A newly released memo written by , a lawyer who previously worked for President Trump, lists a six-point plan to subvert our Republic. Eastman's report begins by arguing then-Vice President should reject the election results in seven battleground states on the pretense they submitted competing electors. That is false. Republicans in those states (i.e., Trump loyalists who promoted disproven voter fraud claims) tried to appoint themselves “alternate electors.” They were never designated electors by state officials and had no legal standing to act as such.

Eastman argued that if Pence acquiesced to this step, Trump would have led in the race for electoral votes by a margin of 232-228. Eastman then claimed that Pence had the authority to declare the election results inconclusive. Responsibility for deciding the next president would fall to members of the House of Representatives, or more precisely, a representative from each state's congressional delegation. Although Republicans were still in the minority following the 2020 elections, they had regained most congressional seats in a slight majority of states. Under those conditions, Eastman believed the House would declare Trump the winner of the presidential election. 

Besides being based on lies, another problem here is that Eastman's argument defies the prevailing interpretation of the Constitution's role for Congress and the vice president when counting electoral votes. The Washington Post describes how Bob Woodward and Robert Acosta's new book, Peril, details Utah Republican Senator Mike Lee's response:

The authors suggest the senator, a former law clerk for Supreme Court Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., was surprised this theory had been circulated by Eastman, a professor at the Chapman University School of Law and former law clerk to Justice Clarence Thomas. Document in hand, and bewildered that theories about dueling electors were still coming from Trump's legal team, Lee made “phone call after phone call” to officials in some of the relevant states, such as Georgia, Pennsylvania and Arizona, he told constituents in a Jan. 27 online town hall, appearing to refer to the Eastman memo without naming its author. A spokesman for Lee did not respond to a request for comment.

Writing for Reason.com, Jonathan H. Adler adds:

On the Election Law Blog, Derek Muller dissects the memo and, among other things, notes how the 2021 Eastman memo contradicts the arguments Eastman made during the 2000 Election controversy (when the Vice President's alleged power to control the counting of Electoral Votes would have been in the hands of Al Gore). As Muller notes, the 2021 memo makes some controversial assumptions (such as that the Electoral Count Act is unconstitutional) and overlooks important facts, such as that the 117th Congress independently adopted the ECA's rules for the counting of electoral votes on January 3, which would have constrained the Vice President's ability to unilaterally control the vote count.

Also on the Election Law Blog, Ned Foley points out some other important legal and practical points the Eastman memo missed that would have doomed the strategy to failure. Among other things, Foley notes, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi could have halted the joint session of Congress and, if necessary, could have stalled proceedings until January 20, when Pence would no longer be Vice President and could no longer seek to manipulate the proceedings as President of the Senate.

The election results seem in doubt to Trump's strongest supporters because they consume hermetically sealed pro-Trump media. That diet doesn't do the political right any good, even practically. If no one challenges your views, they won't get stronger in a natural, healthy way. It also becomes harder to understand why others see things differently. 

Ideological echo chambers aren't a new phenomenon. Trump's victory over Hillary Clinton popped the so-called liberal bubble in 2016. For millions of Hillary voters, the shock of her loss was all more traumatic as they had seen few or no outliers suggesting she was in trouble. Even the Clinton campaign fell victim to fawning press coverage. After the election, the New York Times reported that senior campaign aides began drinking champagne hours before Secretary Clinton lost the election.

Failing to analyze constitutionally dubious behavior exhibited by Trump that fomented an assault on the Capitol Building undermines any future arguments the political right will have against presidents for corrupt and unethical behavior. Moreover, if Pence had acted on Trump's whims, the United States would have faced a constitutional crisis worse than any since the Civil War.

Presidents of both parties have betrayed the Constitution. Objective defenders of liberty must acknowledge that. Putting blinders on to the actions of one side or the other out of deeply misguided beliefs or partisan calculations threatens the very document that made America exceptional. It won't be viewed kindly by future generations.

The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.

Comments are closed.

Security

0 views
American Liberty News

Should We Let Ukraine Fly Its Jets from ‘Sanctuary Bases’ On NATO territory?

SUNDAY PDB – One security expert says: Let Ukraine fly its jets from
- July 21, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Experts Prepare For US Coup Amid Concerns After Trump Shooting

ANALYSIS – The close-call attempted assassination for former President Donald Trump has
- July 21, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Disruptions Linger After IT Update Crashes Computer Systems Worldwide

A major IT outage occurred late Thursday night, wreaking havoc on businesses
- July 20, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Drone Strike Hits Tel Aviv, Evades Israel’s Air Defenses

Israel's vaunted air defenses were breached by a drone strike on Friday
- July 20, 2024

Foreign Affairs

0 views
American Liberty News

Disruptions Linger After IT Update Crashes Computer Systems Worldwide

A major IT outage occurred late Thursday night, wreaking havoc on businesses
- July 20, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Drone Strike Hits Tel Aviv, Evades Israel’s Air Defenses

Israel's vaunted air defenses were breached by a drone strike on Friday
- July 20, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Former CIA Analyst Charged For Acting As Secret Agent For Foreign Country

The Justice Department has indicted a former CIA analyst and a senior
- July 18, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Report: Biden Skipped Crucial Meeting Because Of Early Bedtime

The Wall Street Journal reported Wednesday that President Joe Biden declined an
- July 10, 2024

Business & economics

0 views
American Liberty News

Elon’s ‘Final Straw’ To Cost California Millions

Elon Musk has announced that he will move the headquarters of X and
- July 18, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News
0 views
American Liberty News

Congress Investigating Whether Woke Activists Broke Federal Tax Law With ESG Investment Schemes

A key congressional committee is now investigating whether a liberal activist scheme to
- June 25, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Elizabeth Warren For Fairness?

Today, U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren, also known as the fake Indian, will speak
- June 17, 2024

heath & science

0 views
American Liberty News

Congressman Claims Biden Didn’t Recognize Him Despite Their Friendship

Rep. Seth Moulton (D-Mass.) recently voiced his concerns in an op-ed, highlighting an
- July 21, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee Succumbs To Pancreatic Cancer

Houston, TX - Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee has passed away, succumbing to pancreatic
- July 20, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Matt Gaetz’s RNC Appearance Sparks Online Frenzy

Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz finds himself at the center of yet another social
- July 18, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Lou Dobbs Dead At 78

Former President Donald Trump announced the passing of well-known cable news personality Lou
- July 18, 2024

American Liberty Arms

High Holy Days: Stay Armed & Very Dangerous

High Holy Days. In Judaism, Rosh Hashanah, “Jewish New Year,” and Yom Kippur, “Day of

National Association For Gun Rights Sues ATF Over Its Determination That Forced Reset Triggers (FRT) Are Machine Guns

By Dan Zimmerman The Truth About Guns Michael Cargill was successful in his challenge of the ATF’s

Keep Your Hand Away From The Muzzle

Via The Tactical Professor March 9, 2024 A friend of mine sent this link to

Gun Owners Of America Slams GOP Platform – Is The RNC Soft On The Second Amendment?

Gun Owners of America (GOA), the "only No Compromise #SecondAmendment lobby in Washington," is seeing

At American Liberty News, we eschew the mainstream media’s tightly controlled narrative to provide our readers with real news, real insights, and the means to take action. We seek out insightful coverage – and partner with knowledgeable and experienced people and organizations to bring you the information and insight our readers demand.

 

We humbly seek to provide the tools and information necessary for our readers to decide for themselves what is true and what is right.

American Liberty News ©2022

Evolution Digital Media  |   1900 Reston Metro Plz  |  Suite 600  |  Reston, VA 20190