Ruling Allows Policy to Take Effect While Legal Battles Continue
WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Supreme Court on Tuesday gave the Trump administration the go-ahead to enforce its ban on most transgender individuals serving in the U.S. military, delivering a major win for the White House as legal challenges continue to work their way through lower courts.
The decision came in the form of a 6-3 ruling along ideological lines, with the Court’s conservative majority allowing the policy to take effect while litigation proceeds.
Background: Policy and Pushback
The first Trump administration announced an initial policy shift in 2017, reversing an Obama-era decision that permitted transgender individuals to enlist and serve openly. The new directive prevents those who identify as transgender from joining the military unless they serve in their biological sex and do not seek gender transition surgery or hormones.
Solicitor General D. John Sauer wrote in last month’s application to the Supreme Court that the policy is “materially indistinguishable” from the one Trump ordered during his first term, which the Supreme Court enabled him to enforce.
That policy banned transgender service members but made an exception for some who had already started to transition, in line with rules put in place during former President Obama’s administration. The new policy makes no such exception, deeming any service member with a current diagnosis, history or symptoms of gender dysphoria unfit for military service.
“The Department must ensure it is building ‘One Force’ without subgroups defined by anything other than ability or mission adherence. Efforts to split our troops along the lines of identity weaken our Force and make us vulnerable,” Hegseth wrote in a February memo to senior leadership at the Pentagon.
In the same memo, Hegseth ordered the Defense Department to pause gender-affirming medical care for trans service members. A federal judge later struck down Hegseth’s restrictions as unconstitutional, and the Pentagon resumed care last month.
Opponents have criticized the transgender ban as discriminatory. The White House maintains that the change is necessary to preserve military readiness and cohesion.
This is a breaking news story. Please check back for updates.
READ NEXT: Town Reverses Course After Residents Rally To Save Police
Hum? Can someone fit this teacher for a straight jacket? She is suffering from Trump syndrome and she needs to be confined in a safe room with hospital staff watching her and caring for her at her own expense!
Yes it is discriminatory. The military is not an equal opportunity employer. It never gas been and nor should it be. You can’t serve if your too fat, if you are too short, if you’re too old or too young, if your IQ is too low, if you are physically disabled AND if you suffer from a psychological illness. Take a hard look at that last one I listed. My daughter couldn’t join the Army because she suffered from mild anxiety. Gender Dysphoria is a mental illness. Has been for a long time and recognized in the DSM. Why did they get a pass to join in the first place? It should have never happened but that’s what happens when you have a POTUS that is more of an activist than a president. Transgenders do not belong in the military and this is just a correction of major policy blunder by Democrat activist politicians. People who have a very clear disconnect from reality do not belong in the military. People who have to rely on others to lie to affirm their frail sense of self do not being in the military. A group of people who suffer a 40% suicide rate does not belong in the military. They negatively affect the over all moral of the troops and they simply do not belong in the military. The military is to fight and win wars, not to bend and break their own regulations to make someone feel better about themselves or to pay for their gender affirming nonsense. They live in a fantasy world and war and the business of it is anything but fantasy. There is no time to create special treatment for these people just as there is not time to create special treatment for anyone else that does not meet the entry requirements for military service. So quit the whining about the military being discriminatory and face the reality of the situation just like I had to do. I spent thirteen years in the Army and then got injured. The injury affected my ability to lead by example as an NCO. So I was medically discharged from the Army. It was one of the worst days of my life when they told me my career was over. I have missed the Army every day for the past 24 years. However, I faced the reality that I could not meet the requirements for leading by example and so I knew I had to be discharged. That is reality and the acceptance of reality. People with gender dysphoria cannot even accept the reality of their own existence as the gender they were born as. What other realities will they refuse to accept and how many lives will it cost needlessly. The military is not the place to find out.