With the National Libertarian Party seeming to lend whatever support it can to the Trump presidential campaign, it's time to revisit the long-running argument over third parties, spoilers, vote shaming, and voter agency.
That sounds like a lot, but they are all related. The most important of these points is voter agency – the idea that every individual voter has the power to act in their own interest. Politics has been practiced just about everywhere and, over the long span of time, is very much an anti-voter agency. The public is to be herded as effectively as possible behind a specific candidate or issue and not allowed to stray (or, God forbid, stay home on Election Day).
The tools used to keep the flock in place have varied a bit over time, but the ends have always been the same. As H.L. Mencken put it:
The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.
And so in this presidential election year, like every one before it, the partisan sheep herders for Teams Red and Blue insist that if we do not vote for their guy, then democracy, the rule of law, the economy, the world, and maybe the heavens, will fall.
Or some other such hyperbolic nonsense intended to keep as many people alarmed as possible…right up to the time the polls close (and if your team loses, for as long afterward as your delusional candidate is convinced he can manifest a win from the ether).
This year, we have additional dollops of hyperbole, worry, and alarm. There are protests on college campuses, savage wars abroad, inflation lurking in the economy, and populism and its discontents riding high in the major political parties. To confront this, the major parties have offered two old men running vanity campaigns.
It's…not a good place to be. And a fair chunk of voters understand this, which is why they are really not keen on Trump or Biden, want alternatives in November, and just might seek those alternatives in independent or third-party candidates.
Or for the most despairing, choosing to stay home and not vote at all.
For these people, who dare to think beyond the wire fence the major parties have erected around the electorate, there reaction from the Team Red and Team Blue enforcers is swift, brutal, and personal.
Any voter who cast a ballot for a non-major party nominee wastes that vote. Or being naïve about how politics works. Or the new hotness: supporting a third party is actively supporting the other major party's nominee.
Say you vote for Herb Smith, the reluctant presidential nominee of the Sane Party. He seems likable, it's crazy and he can get through the day without embarrassing himself. You agree with a lot of what he stands for, too.
And so he gets your vote.
Team Red and Team Blue will shout – hysterically, if necessary – that such a vote is really for the other Team's nominee. You didn't just waste your vote on someone who can't win, you effectively took your vote away from a major party that deserved it, and for all intents and purposes gave it to the other Team, which will now be able to carry out its destruction of the cosmos.
This is all nonsense because it assumes that parties/candidates/issues have a standing claim on your vote. Any deviation – any exercise of voter agency – cannot be tolerated.
Like every schoolyard bully, Team Red and Team Blue's bullies are just terrified that someone – or many people – will realize they don't have to put up with the rotten choices on offer.
And stand up to the bullies. They may demand that instead of scaring people into voting for Kang or Kodos, the parties and their nominees earn each vote. If that means they need to be better candidates, so be it. Get busy. And if that's too big of an ask, be prepared to face the consequences on Election Day.
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.
Americans Must Advance Past The Political Duopoly
Will Trump Dump JD Vance?
ANALYSIS – Is Trump regretting his VP pick? Will Trump tell Vance he is “fired”? When former President Donald Trump selected J.D. Vance as his vice presidential candidate soon after surviving an assassination attempt, some called the choice bold and a doubling down on Trumpism.
I said he could help Trump make his case in 2024 and be the GOP standard bearer in 2028. Still, I also said I would have preferred Trump had picked a woman, and that I had some reservations about Vance as VP, including his youth and inexperience.
Fox News’ Kilmeade Fires Back At Racism Allegations
Trump’s ‘Dying Wish’ Exposed – What He Wants If Assassinated
Kamala Harris ‘Owns’ All Of Biden’s Many National Security Failures
Does This Single Fact Signal Our Imminent Financial Collapse?
With the National Libertarian Party seeming to lend whatever support it can to the Trump presidential campaign, it's time to revisit the long-running argument over third parties, spoilers, vote shaming, and voter agency.
That sounds like a lot, but they are all related. The most important of these points is voter agency – the idea that every individual voter has the power to act in their own interest. Politics has been practiced just about everywhere and, over the long span of time, is very much an anti-voter agency. The public is to be herded as effectively as possible behind a specific candidate or issue and not allowed to stray (or, God forbid, stay home on Election Day).
The tools used to keep the flock in place have varied a bit over time, but the ends have always been the same. As H.L. Mencken put it:
And so in this presidential election year, like every one before it, the partisan sheep herders for Teams Red and Blue insist that if we do not vote for their guy, then democracy, the rule of law, the economy, the world, and maybe the heavens, will fall.
Or some other such hyperbolic nonsense intended to keep as many people alarmed as possible…right up to the time the polls close (and if your team loses, for as long afterward as your delusional candidate is convinced he can manifest a win from the ether).
This year, we have additional dollops of hyperbole, worry, and alarm. There are protests on college campuses, savage wars abroad, inflation lurking in the economy, and populism and its discontents riding high in the major political parties. To confront this, the major parties have offered two old men running vanity campaigns.
It's…not a good place to be. And a fair chunk of voters understand this, which is why they are really not keen on Trump or Biden, want alternatives in November, and just might seek those alternatives in independent or third-party candidates.
Or for the most despairing, choosing to stay home and not vote at all.
For these people, who dare to think beyond the wire fence the major parties have erected around the electorate, there reaction from the Team Red and Team Blue enforcers is swift, brutal, and personal.
Any voter who cast a ballot for a non-major party nominee wastes that vote. Or being naïve about how politics works. Or the new hotness: supporting a third party is actively supporting the other major party's nominee.
Say you vote for Herb Smith, the reluctant presidential nominee of the Sane Party. He seems likable, it's crazy and he can get through the day without embarrassing himself. You agree with a lot of what he stands for, too.
And so he gets your vote.
Team Red and Team Blue will shout – hysterically, if necessary – that such a vote is really for the other Team's nominee. You didn't just waste your vote on someone who can't win, you effectively took your vote away from a major party that deserved it, and for all intents and purposes gave it to the other Team, which will now be able to carry out its destruction of the cosmos.
This is all nonsense because it assumes that parties/candidates/issues have a standing claim on your vote. Any deviation – any exercise of voter agency – cannot be tolerated.
Like every schoolyard bully, Team Red and Team Blue's bullies are just terrified that someone – or many people – will realize they don't have to put up with the rotten choices on offer.
And stand up to the bullies. They may demand that instead of scaring people into voting for Kang or Kodos, the parties and their nominees earn each vote. If that means they need to be better candidates, so be it. Get busy. And if that's too big of an ask, be prepared to face the consequences on Election Day.
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.
Norman Leahy
Will Trump Dump JD Vance?
Search
follow us
subscribe
Trending Stories
Will Trump Dump JD Vance?
ANALYSIS – Is Trump regretting his VP pick? WillBacklash Grows As Harley-Davidson Infected With Woke Virus
ANALYSIS – Say it isn’t so! Even asProject 2025 Will Return Sanity To Our Woke Military
ANALYSIS – “I disagree with some of the thingsNew Impeachment Investigation Launched Into Allegations Hunter Biden Invoked Joe’s Name
Congressional investigators are looking into further allegations againstCommentary
Will Trump Dump JD Vance?
Kamala Harris ‘Owns’ All Of Biden’s Many National Security Failures
Does This Single Fact Signal Our Imminent Financial Collapse?
Smoke Shop Shooting: 71-Year-Old Stops Armed Burglar
Security
Trump’s ‘Dying Wish’ Exposed – What He Wants If Assassinated
Kamala Harris ‘Owns’ All Of Biden’s Many National Security Failures
US Support For Israel In Its War Must Be ‘Ironclad’
US Fighters Intercept Chinese And Russian Bombers Near Alaska
Foreign Affairs
Trump’s ‘Dying Wish’ Exposed – What He Wants If Assassinated
Attacks Disrupt Paris: Major Infrastructure Targeted Hours Before Olympic Games
US Fighters Intercept Chinese And Russian Bombers Near Alaska
Disruptions Linger After IT Update Crashes Computer Systems Worldwide
Business & economics
Does This Single Fact Signal Our Imminent Financial Collapse?
Elon’s ‘Final Straw’ To Cost California Millions
Meet The Man Who Tracks Pelosi’s Investments – Guess His Earnings Last Month?
Congress Investigating Whether Woke Activists Broke Federal Tax Law With ESG Investment Schemes
heath & science
Old School Sold For Next To Nothing To Planned Parenthood
Elon Musk On Estranged Child: ‘Killed By The Woke Mind Virus’
Congressman Claims Biden Didn’t Recognize Him Despite Their Friendship
Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee Succumbs To Pancreatic Cancer
American Liberty Arms
Trump Shooter Put in Range Time Weeks Before Assassination Attempt
Armed Georgia Man And A Labradoodle Capture Inmate
More Anti-Gun Groups Fabricating Mass Shooting Data
The Truck Gun For Active Killer Interdiction: Realistic?
At American Liberty News, we eschew the mainstream media’s tightly controlled narrative to provide our readers with real news, real insights, and the means to take action. We seek out insightful coverage – and partner with knowledgeable and experienced people and organizations to bring you the information and insight our readers demand.
We humbly seek to provide the tools and information necessary for our readers to decide for themselves what is true and what is right.
TOP TAGS
TOP CATEGORIES
FEATURES
American Liberty News ©2022
Evolution Digital Media | 1900 Reston Metro Plz | Suite 600 | Reston, VA 20190