The House and Senate overcame the objections of their performative wings to approve a $95 billion foreign aid bill. Along with the splash of cash is a provision that would ban or force the sale of Chinese-owned social media company TikTok.
The votes were bipartisan and based on the idea that the wildly popular platform is little more than a Chinese intelligence/propaganda device that steals users’ data and hands it off to the ChiComs.
Who, presumably, will do something nefarious with it.
However, nefarious means and actions are not limited to the CCP. Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul (who ultimately did not vote on the Senate version of the bill) wrote in Reason there are substantial constitutional issues at play in the TikTok kerfuffle – few of which got much attention among the “China hysterics” in Congress:
I think the Supreme Court will ultimately rule [a ban or forced sale] unconstitutional, because it would violate the First Amendment rights of over 100 million Americans who use TikTok to express themselves.
In addition, I believe the Court will rule that the forced sale violates the Fifth Amendment. Under the Constitution, the government cannot take your property without accusing and convicting you of a crime—in short, without due process. Since Americans are part of TikTok’s ownership, they will eventually get their day in court.
The Court could also conclude that naming and forcing the sale of a specific company amounts to a bill of attainder, legislation that targets a single entity.
Constitutional niceties usually don’t carry much weight with our political class. But a court test of a forced government divestiture would provide a fascinating and broadly horrifying spectacle.
Paul also notes that in return for a forced sale or ban, the Chinese government could turn its attention to American companies with major presences in China – Apple for one. Tesla, too. Those companies might be forced to bend even further to Chinese demands for user data. And back in the USA, what’s to stop the federal government from banning other Chinese companies with dodgy data practices?
Once it starts rolling, the ban-wagon can extend to any number of foreign entities that fit the moment’s hysteria.
It might all end – abruptly and with many bruised egos – in the federal courts. However, it should not take court action to remind the worthies that their actions have constitutional, political, and economic implications. You know – the things that are much more important than any particular incumbent’s desire to remain in office.
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.
Norman Leahy has written about national and Virginia politics for more than 30 years with outlets ranging from The Washington Post to BearingDrift.com. A consulting writer, editor, recovering think tank executive and campaign operative, Norman lives in Virginia.
Norman Leahy has written about national and Virginia politics for more than 30 years with outlets ranging from The Washington Post to BearingDrift.com. A consulting writer, editor, recovering think tank executive and campaign operative, Norman lives in Virginia.
Capt. Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger, the celebrated pilot who saved 155 lives during the “Miracle
At American Liberty News, we eschew the mainstream media’s tightly controlled narrative to provide our readers with real news, real insights, and the means to take action. We seek out insightful coverage – and partner with knowledgeable and experienced people and organizations to bring you the information and insight our readers demand.
We humbly seek to provide the tools and information necessary for our readers to decide for themselves what is true and what is right.
Bipartisan TikTok Ban Passage Shows Politicians’ True Masters
The House and Senate overcame the objections of their performative wings to approve a $95 billion foreign aid bill. Along with the splash of cash is a provision that would ban or force the sale of Chinese-owned social media company TikTok.
The votes were bipartisan and based on the idea that the wildly popular platform is little more than a Chinese intelligence/propaganda device that steals users’ data and hands it off to the ChiComs.
Who, presumably, will do something nefarious with it.
However, nefarious means and actions are not limited to the CCP. Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul (who ultimately did not vote on the Senate version of the bill) wrote in Reason there are substantial constitutional issues at play in the TikTok kerfuffle – few of which got much attention among the “China hysterics” in Congress:
Constitutional niceties usually don’t carry much weight with our political class. But a court test of a forced government divestiture would provide a fascinating and broadly horrifying spectacle.
Paul also notes that in return for a forced sale or ban, the Chinese government could turn its attention to American companies with major presences in China – Apple for one. Tesla, too. Those companies might be forced to bend even further to Chinese demands for user data. And back in the USA, what’s to stop the federal government from banning other Chinese companies with dodgy data practices?
Once it starts rolling, the ban-wagon can extend to any number of foreign entities that fit the moment’s hysteria.
It might all end – abruptly and with many bruised egos – in the federal courts. However, it should not take court action to remind the worthies that their actions have constitutional, political, and economic implications. You know – the things that are much more important than any particular incumbent’s desire to remain in office.
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.
READ NEXT: Kennedy Candidacy Exposes Weaknesses Of Both Major Parties
Norman Leahy
Norman Leahy has written about national and Virginia politics for more than 30 years with outlets ranging from The Washington Post to BearingDrift.com. A consulting writer, editor, recovering think tank executive and campaign operative, Norman lives in Virginia.
Norman Leahy
Norman Leahy has written about national and Virginia politics for more than 30 years with outlets ranging from The Washington Post to BearingDrift.com. A consulting writer, editor, recovering think tank executive and campaign operative, Norman lives in Virginia.
Search
follow us
subscribe
TRENDING STORIES
Fresh Staffer Relationship Claims Rock Ruben Gallego After Ethics Win
Ditching ‘Exquisite’ Systems: Inside The Pentagon’s Mass-Munitions Blitz
When Dissent Goes Corporate: Neville Roy Singham Meets Jay Clayton’s Grand Jury
Not Mission Capable: The Flaws In Trump’s Interim Air Force One
SECURITY
US Troops Hit By Explosion While Destroying Downed Iranian Drone
A U.S. service member was killed in northern Iraq while participating in the controlled
Army Spent $469 Million On Texas Artillery Plant That Produced Zero Usable Shell Parts
A Texas ammunition factory built with nearly half a billion dollars in taxpayer funding
Hegseth Releases Dramatic Image Of Chabahar Control Tower Collapse As US Intensifies Strikes On Iran
Friday campaign appears to mark the heaviest day of renewed U.S. operations Secretary of
Tehran Billboard Depicts Trump In Coffin As US-Iran Conflict Escalates
A giant billboard depicting a disheveled caricature of President Donald Trump lying in a
FOREIGN AFFAIRS
US Troops Hit By Explosion While Destroying Downed Iranian Drone
A U.S. service member was killed in northern Iraq while participating in the controlled
Memo Alleges China Sought To Pay American Journalists to Publish Anti-Trump Stories In 2020
A newly declassified CIA intelligence note alleges that the Chinese government sought to pay
Trump Praises Surprise Positive Gesture From Iran
President Donald Trump announced Wednesday evening that Iran had allowed an American citizen trapped
Joe Scarborough Asks Ro Khanna If West Bank Detention Was A Publicity Stunt
MS NOW host Joe Scarborough questioned Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) about allegations that the
BUSINESS & ECONOMICS
Trump Threatens New Tariffs Over Canada’s Wildfire Smoke
President Donald Trump threatened Friday to impose new tariffs on Canada, accusing Ottawa of
Xbox CEO’s Federal Reserve Appointment Sparks Backlash Following Microsoft Layoffs
The Federal Reserve is facing criticism after appointing Xbox CEO Asha Sharma to a
The AI Jobs Apocalypse Just Failed Its First Contact With The Evidence
Imagine a chief executive standing before his investors after a bruising quarter. He overhired
Trump Orders Immediate Halt to Trade With Spain Over NATO Dispute
President Donald Trump dramatically escalated his pressure campaign against NATO allies on Wednesday by
HEALTH & SCIENCE
FDA Rescinds Taylor Farms Lettuce Cyclospora Alert, Issues Apology
The Food and Drug Administration has reversed a key finding in its investigation of
Trump Threatens New Tariffs Over Canada’s Wildfire Smoke
President Donald Trump threatened Friday to impose new tariffs on Canada, accusing Ottawa of
JD Vance Says He Didn’t Know Biden Underwent Brain Surgeries, Faults Media During Rogan Interview
Vice President JD Vance expressed astonishment after learning during an interview with podcast host
Famous Captain Chesley ‘Sully’ Sullenberger Announces Alzheimer’s Diagnosis
Capt. Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger, the celebrated pilot who saved 155 lives during the “Miracle
At American Liberty News, we eschew the mainstream media’s tightly controlled narrative to provide our readers with real news, real insights, and the means to take action. We seek out insightful coverage – and partner with knowledgeable and experienced people and organizations to bring you the information and insight our readers demand.
We humbly seek to provide the tools and information necessary for our readers to decide for themselves what is true and what is right.
TOP TAGS
TOP CATEGORIES
FEATURES
American Liberty News ©2024
Evolution Digital Media
1900 Reston Metro Plz
Suite 600
Reston, VA 20190