The Church of England has reportedly instructed its clergy to make changes to popular Christmas carols and Advent hymns to avoid “causing unnecessary offense.” The directive, which was reportedly sent via email to priests in the diocese of Birmingham, has ignited a debate over the intersection of religious tradition and political correctness in the modern Church.
According to a whistleblowing vicar, several well-known Christmas carols have been flagged for their potentially “problematic” content, with hymns such as O Come, O Come, Emmanuel and Lo, He Comes With Clouds Descending coming under scrutiny. The issue appears to center around the lyrics’ theological implications.
The hymn O Come, O Come, Emmanuel has reportedly been criticized for suggesting that other religions might be “outside of God’s grace.” Similarly, the Advent hymn Lo, He Comes With Clouds Descending was flagged for reinforcing the belief that Jesus Christ is the “true Messiah.”
The email, which was sent to clergy in the Birmingham diocese, urged priests to “use language that won’t add further confusion or tension or take away anything from the good news of the Nativity.” According to Christian doctrine, the good news of the Nativity quite literally is that Jesus Christ — the One True Messiah — was born, and by minimizing that key tenet, the Church of England is undermining Christmas in its entirety, drawing sharp criticism from those who believe the Church is compromising its core beliefs to appease a politically correct agenda.
This is not the first time the Church of England has faced criticism for embracing what some view as “woke” ideology. In recent years, the institution has made several moves that critics argue have prioritized progressive social causes over traditional Christian doctrine. For example, in 2023, the Church launched a project aimed at exploring the use of “gender-neutral” language to refer to God. Some have argued that this initiative undermines the traditional understanding of God as revealed in Scripture and Christian teaching.
Another controversial decision came in 2023, when the General Synod, the Church of England’s legislative body, voted in favor of recognizing same-sex marriages by allowing priests to give blessings to same-sex couples.
In both cases, the Church of England’s leadership has been accused of bending to the pressures of modern social movements at the expense of biblical orthodoxy. The recent move to alter Christmas carols is seen by many as part of this broader shift toward appeasing secular and progressive sensibilities, rather than upholding traditional Christian values.
Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby, who has been at the forefront of the Church of England’s move toward a more progressive stance, has also faced significant criticism for his handling of sexual abuse allegations. Last month, Welby announced that he would step down from his role as the principal leader of the Church amid growing accusations that he had covered up allegations of sexual and physical abuse carried out by the late John Smyth QC, a former leader of Church of England summer camps for children.
The directive to modify Christmas carols has only heightened divisions within the Church of England. Traditionalists argue that Christmas carols, as a central part of the Christian faith, should be celebrated for their deep theological meaning and historical significance. Altering the lyrics to avoid offense, they argue, compromises the very essence of what Christmas represents—the birth of Jesus Christ as the Savior of the world.
READ NEXT: Archbishop Warns Lord’s Prayer May Be ‘Problematic’
If they came to me to “encourage” me to change them, I would say when you go to the Jews and Muslims and “encourage” them the same and they do it, we can discuss it. Because it won’t happen! The point of Christianity is devotion to Christ. Not to go against the Bible and say EVERYONE is saved even if you are a Satanist.
All religions are fake!