John Fetterman’s Absurd Argument Against Voter ID

United States House of Representatives - Office of Ruben Gallego, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
American Liberty News
- June 4, 2026
0 views 3 min
1 minute read

Arizona Democratic Sen. Ruben Gallego is launching an effort to challenge a new Trump Administration immigration policy that could require many green card applicants to leave the United States and complete the process abroad.

According to a report from The Hill, Gallego is not only seeking to overturn the policy itself but is also pursuing a procedural strategy that could make it easier for Congress to reverse the change.

The dispute revolves around a recent U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) policy affecting how certain immigrants obtain lawful permanent residency.

David Berkowitz from New York, NY, USA, CC BY 2.0 , via Wikimedia Commons
4 minute read

Last week, Pennsylvania U.S. Senate candidate Democrat John Fetterman said that requiring a voter I.D. is “insidious and unnecessary,” “outrageous,” “illogical,” “unfair,” and “simply voter suppression.” He says that concerns about vote fraud are a myth. But if concerns about vote fraud are a delusion, it is a delusion shared by virtually all other countries and by the vast majority of American voters (79%).

All 47 European countries, except for parts of the United Kingdom, require a government-issued photo I.D. to vote. The U.K. has introduced legislation to mandate I.D.s, which are already required in Northern Ireland and parts of England.

In some countries, even driver’s licenses aren’t acceptable forms of voter identity verification. The Czech Republic and Russia requires passports or military-issued I.D.s. Most other countries use national identity cards to also verify citizenship. Still others, such as Colombia and our neighbor, Mexico, require biometric voter I.D.s. Our other neighbor, Canada, also requires a government-issued photo voter I.D. to vote.

Despite Fetterman’s claims of voter suppression, requiring voter photo I.D.s has increased voter turnout in other countries and U.S. states. Turnout in Mexico increased after sweeping reforms were enacted in 1991. Inconveniently, people have to go in person to apply for the I.D.s and then pick them up at a later date. For some Mexicans, that means trips each way of almost 100 miles. Absentee ballots are completely banned.

You would think that voter turnout would plummet, but that’s not what happened. In the three presidential elections after Mexico’s reforms, 68% of eligible citizens voted compared to only 59% in the three elections before the changes.

When Georgia took the modest step of requiring voters to include the last four digits of their Social Security numbers on absentee ballots, the reform was met with corporate boycotts. Compare that with Europe, where 35 of the 47 countries entirely ban absentee voting for citizens who reside domestically.

Another ten countries have absentee ballots, but voters can only collect them by going in person and presenting photo I.D. Most of those ten countries limit absentee voting to those who can provide third-party verification of hospitalization or military service.

Even during the COVID lockdowns, unlike the U.S., Europe made few exceptions. Poland allowed mail-in ballots for everyone in 2020 as a one-time measure, as did two cities in Russia. But Poland’s plan played out poorly. Other countries saw these problems and were dissuaded from following suit. France made very limited exceptions, temporarily allowing sick or at-risk individuals to vote absentee.

In all European and developed countries, strict chain of custody regulations exist for ballot boxes. Ballot boxes being left out unattended at 3 a.m., as we saw in Pennsylvania, is not something that we see outside of the United States. Other countries not only monitor ballot boxes at all times, but they also check government-issued photo I.D.s to ensure who is putting ballots in the boxes.

Although the rest of the developed world also debates how to balance voter fraud prevention with ease of voting, there is agreement across the political spectrum (e.g., Canada and Mexico) that people need to verify their identities.

Some countries have learned their lesson the hard way. In Northern Ireland, where a bitter sectarian conflict extended to hardball electoral machinations, voter fraud was described as “widespread and systemic” on all sides. As a result, both Conservative and Labour governments instituted reforms. In 1985, conservative Margaret Thatcher passed legislation requiring voters to identify themselves before being given a ballot.

After a 1998 government report found that medical cards were used as I.D.s and could be “easily forged or applied for fraudulently,” the left wing Labour government made voter identification cards much more difficult to forge and took other measures to prevent people from registering to vote multiple times. These anti-fraud provisions led to an immediate 11 percent reduction in total registrations.

Former IRA Belfast commander Brendan Hughes recounted to a group of academics in their 2017 report how he had used a fleet of taxis to ferry fraudulent voters from one polling station to another, and how wigs, clothes, and glasses were used to alter voters’ appearances.

Countries such as Sweden, France and Canada are hardly anti-democratic, yet they are out of step with John Fetterman’s ideas of election security. Perhaps it is Fetterman’s ideas that will prove anti-democratic.

This article originally appeared in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News. Republished with permission.

READ NEXT: Dr. Oz Administers Medical Aid to Flight Passenger >>

Picture of John Lott

John Lott

Dr. John R. Lott, Jr. founded the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC). An economist and a world-recognized expert on guns and crime, Lott served the Trump administration as the Senior Advisor for Research and Statistics at the Department of Justice's Office of Legal Policy.

41 Comments
    Oirish1953

    Perhaps Mr Fetterman you can arrange that no ID is required for the following:

    •To purchase a gun.
    •To fly on a commercial plane.
    •To ride a train.
    •To take a cruise.
    •To open a bank account.
    •To get a bank loan.
    •To get a mortgage.
    •To get a library card.
    •To receive any kind of health care.
    •To operate a car, private plane, heavy equipment
    •Open any utility account.
    •And much, much, more!!!

    Mr. Fetterman until you eliminate all ID requirements do not tell me that requiring an ID to vote is unjustified, illogical, racist, unfair, or suppression. These are hollow arguments as ID is required for almost any activity in our society.

    You are just another deceptive, lying, dishonest, progressive politician that wants insecure elections so you Democommies can cheat and steal elections.

    Wake up voters, keep these communists out of office and vote out the communist progressive politicians that are currently in office.

      John

      To go to a bar.
      To buy alcohol.
      To buy tobacco products.
      To get a speeding ticket.

        Jack Hills

        To get married. Didn’t you have to show your ID to marry that pretty woman, wife #2?

      glenn

      Can I copy and paste what you said on my Facebook? I love it, I know why they want no ID, we all do,

    mbr722

    If you have a problem identifying yourself when asked at a polling station then you are hiding something! Simple as that! No American citizen who has the right to vote should be scared of bring asked for identification. We do it at the doctors and dentists office together with handing over our insurance cards to be photographed by various personnnel. No one has ever mentioned being worried about that, have they?

      Gerry

      No — he is just as corrupt as , the clintons,obamas,bidens,pelosis,schiff-for-brains and many many more.

    Joe

    U need a ID to purchase almost anything.Especially to vote, I hacve always had to show an ID to vote, even though they all know me.Fetterman is a radical,liberal,socialist,marxist, hje even admits it,we don’t need clowns like him in government.

    John M Parnet

    Things are obvious anywhere in the world, on nearly every topic: those who favour more contrôle will typically be those who are the l’est inclined to cheating. And the reverse applies !!!

    Joe

    Fetterman is radical,liberal,socialist,marxist, just like the squad,he isn’t fit for government. Don’t censor me again,fot the truth.

    El-Tejas

    fetterman’s entire tirade is fallacious! Voter laws do not spread gradually without notice. And they do not cause serious harm. They are in fact beneficial in protecting the integrity of the voting process. They are NOT illogical nor unfair. And they do not suppress the vote of anyone legally qualified and registered to vote. And voter fraud exists. It is neither a myth nor an illusion. .

    Robert M Ryan

    Why is there a picture of Dr Oz on this article? It has nothing to do with him. Doesn’t AOL have any pics of Fetterman? Sure it does, so why not show him?

    Bernie C

    Most every rational person understands that Mr Fetterman’s arguments against voter ID hold no water and are not logical. Apparently it doesn’t matter. The leftists (pronounced Marxists) control the narrative in our major media and institutes of higher learning. Do they actually believe that Voter ID laws are oppressive to black and brown people in 2022? Why? They are pretending that certain groups are too poor or stupid to obtain a Govt ID, and that is an accepted “false narrative”. It’s humiliating and sad that leftists are willing to cast some of our citizens in that light.
    These same people WILL find additional “reasons” to ensure there is MASS Mail-out ballots with mass mail-back votes. Very very hard to account for those ballots. Mail-in balloting will be the end of our republic. Electronic machines were the start. Our real citizens, those who aren’t trying to control our elections, who just want to vote and participate, know that casting their ballot in person, and proving their identity is an ABSOLUTE MUST for election integrity. There truly is only one reason to outright demand NO voter ID requirements and promote mail-in ballots- Subversion.
    Personally, I would tolerate 2 weeks of in-person voting, with ID, and even partisans at every box. That would be safer and have much more integrity than what we have now. To hell with making such an important process “easy”. Our country doesn’t need “easy”. Many citizens are losing faith in our election integrity, and that is by the design of these leftists. When good people feel it no longer matters, it’s over.. The Marxists win..

    P Moe

    The 2020 presidential election had very low margins in several states. There was a reported 15 million non citizens (primarily from Mexico) living in the U S before The last election and 4 million plus since. It stands to reason that every state should requite voter ID. My guess is that few Citizens do not already have an ID acceptable for voting purposes.

    William

    Fetterrman is crazy liberal lunatic so here’s a Let’s Go Brandon to him

    Lucy

    We need voters Picture ID paper ballots machine is to easily changed paper only in ink no illegals at all ever in American Election

      Wboswell5

      You are extremely right Lucy. We also need to make all ballot boxes ILLEGAL IN ALL 50 STATES AND TERRITORIES… They are to damn easy to stuff. As we found out in 2020. The dimoshits took complete control in stuffing them. IF THERE ARE PAPER BALLOTS THEY MUST BE SERIALLY NUMBERED ALL ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND MONITORED…

    Stacy M

    It’s clear why the left wants to protect vote fraud. They don’t think they can legitimately win elections.

    If Republicans were committing vote fraud, the left would be clamoring for anti-fraud measures. But since it benefits the left, they’ll fight any sort of reform to ensure election integrity.

    When Trump ran for office, he promised to fight election fraud. Unfortunately, he got a lot of push-back on that from blue states and he abandoned the effort. Failing to keep that one promise ended up biting him in the back.

    Deplorable Mark

    Black folks all look alike, so they can’t get IDs, dontcha know.

    Pete noffke

    Voter fraud comes from corrupt politicians. I wish our system did not invite fraud but it does. Requiring ID I’m afraid is likely the only thing left to do. It’ll be interesting how they corrupt that after a period of time.

    Phyll2

    You can beat this dead horse all day long, but the democrats insistence on no voter ID is just so they can more easily commit fraud. Everybody knows that, especially the democrats who are only doing that because nobody has punched them in the nose over it yet. They need utterly beaten down to nothing, then you might see them change their propaganda based election schemes. It’s all lies and propaganda, that is the democrat party and all you have to do is look at all the promises that have been broken by democrats. Like, they haven’t done anything to make America better, the border isn’t better, crime isn’t better, sure nobody’s in jail but that just exacerbates crime, not better, can’t get anyone to sign up for the military, military is demoralized with their wannabe girls leadership, what kind of soldiers worry about what these woke bastards worry about, the economy is in the toilet and the national debt is beyond paying back, inflation is at new record highs, Biden has destroyed our energy self sufficiency without any alternative to take it’s place, well, what is better? Race relations? The labor market? Are stores shelves fully stocked? Hell California still wants kids to wear masks to school and get jabbed with a deadly genetic infusion of messenger RNA to change the way their body works. I might add, against the laws of international treaties. Biden promised to bring the country together and then spent every second since Jan.20, 2021 tearing it apart. Culminating in that nauseating speech the other day where he again threatened patriotic Americans with sending the military out to kill them. What a guy. Again, how is that bringing them together? It’s not. Hopefully it’s just more lies. Big talk from a big thug. If it isn’t he better say his prayers for real this time.

    Patsy Lopez De Victoria

    You should have to show a picture photo (Driver’s License) and Voter Registration card every time you vote. Should be the law. And if don’t have it, you don’t vote. And mail in ballets ought to have a copy of the same.

      Calvin Johnston

      Mail in ballots are simply another method of election corruption.

    Calvin Johnston

    People have to provide ID to buy a beer, to get a loan to buy a car, to get into a ball game in many cases. And it should be illegal to require ID to vote. That is simply asking for election fraud.

    A-Jay

    Candidate Fetterman suggests requiring a voter I.D. is “insidious and unnecessary,” “outrageous,” “illogical,” “unfair,” and “simply voter suppression.” 
    If that’s the case go and try to open a bank account, buy property, sign a contract, walk into a secure location, etc. and see what ID one requires.
    With that rhetoric, spin, and edict from Fetterman, a wannabe, it just doesn’t make sense. And, to think, he wants to represent his constituents in DC?

    michael

    Apparently, Mr. Fetterman is racist
    Any black person would be aggrieved by Mr. Fetterman
    telling them they are unable to do a simple task that a
    white person accomplish.

    Pure rubbish and racist.

    M. zitterman
    mikiesmoky at aol com

    Sterling Pennington

    Mr. Fetterman, do you know that our government is starting to propose ending the use of cash for anything and everything? How are the disenfranchised going to live if they cannot keep their identification?

    James E. Embry

    Fetterman is either a fool or a tool of the Democratic machine!

    Jasper

    Photo ID presented in order to vote is a most reasonable request. Those who disagree must be existing with their head up their behind.

    charles A wilkins

    We are not some Chinese Communist Country joe biden and never will be,
    democrats raise their right hand take an oath to defend our Constitution, yet they spend most of their time trying to destroy, it’s time for traitors and oath breakers to be voted out of office, some need time in jail for review their lost American values Stop trying to pump up your image it’s not happening.

    Gerry

    “Insidious, unnecessary,illogical” — those words seem to fit fettermen to a “T”. Unfair and voter suppression are just words used by all liberal democrats who are looking for the illegal vote. I also agree the ID should be more than a driver’s license as it seems several states are just handing out a license to any illegal who asks for one. BUT I also have not witnessed any progress in fighting voter fraud so we could very well have another 2020 fiasco.

    Jawad

    Tell you what: let’s cancel Fetterman’s customer ID for his bank and watch every Tom, Dick and Harry come into the bank and bleed his bank account DRY! Think he would learn his lesson the hard way? NOOO, his brain lives in an alternate universe.

    Bud

    Fetterman could best be described as the exit point on the human body.

    Jean

    Yes we need voter ID. Please DONT vote for an idiot
    Who says we DONT.

    Will March

    Every other nation defends, protects, and enforces its borders. We hear not a word of criticism. If THEY are Correct and Reasonable to do so, then The US is also. As others have commented, If it is reasonable to DEMAND ID for the most routine and inconsequential transactions, it is Far More Rational and Equitable to Require ID to confirm a person’s Legitimate Claim as a full participant in the Constitutionally Defined Process of Self Government that makes this Nation UNIQUE on the planet.

    The migrants who have risked their lives to make their way to our borders CAME HERE for Exactly the Freedoms and Protections this man is trying to dismantle.
    They are NOT STUPID, Nor lazy. They will recognize the perverse lies that have been used to lure them here to be used as Pawns in the effort to erase our Constitution.

Comments are closed.

Security

0 views
American Liberty News
0 views
American Liberty News
0 views
American Liberty News

US Considers Expanding NATO Nuclear-Sharing Program Into Eastern Europe: Report

The United States is reportedly discussing a significant expansion of NATO's nuclear-sharing
- June 2, 2026
0 views
American Liberty News

Trump Names Housing Finance Leader Bill Pulte As Acting DNI

The FHFA director will lead the U.S. intelligence community on an acting
- June 2, 2026

Foreign Affairs

0 views
American Liberty News

California Tech CEO Arrested For Allegedly Supplying US Equipment To Iran’s Nuclear Program

A California technology company CEO has been arrested and charged with allegedly
- June 3, 2026
0 views
American Liberty News
0 views
American Liberty News

French Left-Wing Leader Claims France Was Never A White Or Christian Nation

A senior leader of France's hard-left La France Insoumise (LFI) party is
- June 2, 2026
0 views
American Liberty News

US Considers Expanding NATO Nuclear-Sharing Program Into Eastern Europe: Report

The United States is reportedly discussing a significant expansion of NATO's nuclear-sharing
- June 2, 2026

Business & economics

0 views
American Liberty News

Insider Trading Investigation Launched Into Ex-Congressman George Santos

Disgraced former Congressman George Santos is once again under federal scrutiny, this time
- June 3, 2026
0 views
American Liberty News
0 views
American Liberty News

Treasury Department Proposes Commemorative $250 Bill Featuring Trump Portrait

President Donald Trump may soon become the face of a brand-new $250 bill
- May 30, 2026
0 views
American Liberty News

Report: Billionaire Republican Businessman Flees America Amid Rising Taxes

Silicon Valley billionaire and longtime Trump ally Peter Thiel has reportedly moved his
- May 29, 2026

heath & science

0 views
American Liberty News
0 views
American Liberty News

How Ken Paxton Finally Brought Texas Children’s Hospital To Justice

There is a particular kind of public servant who treats a press release
0 views
American Liberty News

Longtime Florida Democrat Frederica Wilson To Retire From Congress

Rep. Frederica Wilson announced Friday that she will retire from Congress at the
- May 29, 2026
0 views
American Liberty News

Trump Team Reportedly Moving Ebola-Exposed Americans To Kenya

The Trump administration is preparing to quarantine and potentially treat Americans exposed to
- May 27, 2026

American Liberty Arms

GunTuber Legend Dugan Ashley Arrested By Feds: Free Speech Concerns, And What It Could Mean For Content Creators

By The Notorious FDE TacticalSh!t In the wild world of gun content on YouTube, few names carry

NRA, FPC, SAF Sue Maryland Over Glock-Style Handgun Ban

By AmmoLand Editor Duncan Johnson Ammoland Maryland Gov. Wes Moore signed SB 334 into law, and

Virginia Officials Rebel: Sheriffs And Prosecutors Refuse To Enforce New Gun Ban

By John Crump Ammoland As the deadline for the new Virginia gun laws approaches, Governor Abigail Spanberger’s master

Pakistan Deploys Thousands Of Troops, Jet Fighter Squadron To Saudi Arabia

Pakistan has deployed 8,000 troops, a ​squadron of fighter jets, and an air defense system to

At American Liberty News, we eschew the mainstream media’s tightly controlled narrative to provide our readers with real news, real insights, and the means to take action. We seek out insightful coverage – and partner with knowledgeable and experienced people and organizations to bring you the information and insight our readers demand.

 

We humbly seek to provide the tools and information necessary for our readers to decide for themselves what is true and what is right.

American Liberty News ©2024

Evolution Digital Media

1900 Reston Metro Plz

Suite 600

Reston, VA 20190