Quebec: Attempting to Do Immigration Right

The White House, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
American Liberty News
- July 15, 2024
0 views 2 min

, a progressive host and former press secretary for President Joe Biden, voiced deep concerns this weekend about the climate of fear and violence, supposedly towards journalists, following the near assassination of former President .

During an appearance on ' “” with , Psaki addressed the tension and the possibility of violence in the wake of the assassination attempt. She emphasized that attributing the attack to Democrats and the media only heightens fears and escalates the risk.

Even as the Biden administration has effectively erased the southern border of the United States, our neighbors to the North seem to be waking up to the importance of borders. Quebec Premier François Legault, whose CAQ party (Coalition Avenir Québec/Coalition for the Future of Quebec) won a majority by running on a responsible immigration platform, has secured a second term. And this time it appears that even more voters were attracted by CAQ’s promises to protect French as Québec’s official language; to give preference to Francophone immigrants and to cap migration at 50,000 individuals per year.

This is not to say that CAQ’s positions didn’t create controversy. Legault triggered a media firestorm when he suggested that bringing in immigrants who are unable to speak French would be “suicidal.” Nevertheless, his assertion is correct. Successful immigration programs require migrants to assimilate into the receiving society. And the ability to speak the lingua franca is a superhighway to assimilation.

Traditionally, Quebec has seen immigration as a means of strengthening its French identity. The province administers its own immigration program, distinct from that run by the Canadian federal government. And that program gives a clear preference to speakers of French, Quebec’s official language.

Over the last decade, however, the percentage of Anglophone migrants being allowed to settle in Quebec has increased significantly. And the Québecois, quite reasonably, do not want to commit socio-political suicide by allowing themselves to become outnumbered by people who do not understand the local culture – which derives from that of France, not Great Britain.

There is an immutable relationship between any language and the various cultural cues that accompany it. As Language Magazine put it: “To interact with a language means to do so with the culture which is its reference point. We could not understand a culture without having direct access to its language because of their intimate connection.” Quite simply put, Quebec wouldn’t be what it is if it weren’t French.  

The leaders of CAQ have seized on a concept of monumental import, something that Québecois voters understand intuitively: Arriving in Québec with the ability to speak French sets up newly arrived immigrants for success. And that, in turn, makes immigration a benefit, rather than a liability for Quebec. Ultimately, why permit immigration at all if it doesn’t benefit the receiving nation?

And make no mistake, the policies that appeal to Quebec’s voters have nothing to do with racism. According to Canada’s 2014 National Household Survey (roughly analogous to the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey), the vast majority of migrants to Quebec come from Africa and the Middle East (i.e. they aren’t Caucasians from Europe). Any racism in this equation would come from presuming that most Francophones are Caucasian.

While the United States does not have a de jure official language, its de facto official language is English. Nevertheless, only a tiny percentage of the million-plus immigrants we accept each year are English speakers. Instead, the U.S. welcomes migrants who arrive without any ability to communicate in English, which reduces their prospects for economic success and slows their integration into American society.

The inability to earn a living leads to reliance on public assistance that costs taxpayers billions. This makes most newly arrived immigrants a fiscal liability for the United States. And rather than working for the U.S., our immigration policies often seem as though they are deliberately calculated to undermine the aspects of American society that made our country such a driver of immigrant success in the period between the Civil War and the end of World War II.

Rather than rewarding foreign trespassers for violating our borders, we should restructure our immigration laws to give preference to immigrants who have the ability to communicate in English and who possess job skills that are needed to drive our economy. Making such reforms would set migrants up for success and eliminate much of the chaos that Team Biden’s laissez-faire approach to immigration law has created along our southern border. 

And, as with Quebec, this has nothing to do with racism. The largest populations of English speakers outside of the United States are in India, the Philippines, the Caribbean and Africa – not exactly areas populated by European Caucasians.

If only they would pay attention, American politicians could learn a few lessons from their Francophone neighbors to the North.

The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of American Liberty News.

READ NEXT: Communist China Has Been Detaining American Officials in COVID Camps for Two Years >>

2 Comments
    John Isoldi, Sr.

    While the model examined by Mr. O’Brien does make many valid (and quite important) points, the Quebécois have succeeded in alienating themselves and their French-based culture from the rest of Canadian society. In some instances, they can be quite rude to non-Francophones. Rather, this is the antithesis of America’s traditional notion of societal assimilation. The fault lies with the USA’s overly-generous Social Welfare entitlements which do NOT encourage assimilation.

Leave a Reply

Security

0 views
American Liberty News

Trump Will Make US Military World’s ‘Most Modern, Lethal And Powerful’

MONDAY PDB – The US needs to rebuild its military might. Trump and
- July 15, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Terrorism Is A Threat. Constitutional Carry Is The Solution

If you want to combat terrorism, there are a lot of things
- July 13, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Israel Ready To Invade Lebanon To Destroy Iran’s Terror Proxy, Hezbollah

ANALYSIS – Will this provoke a wider regional war with Iran? Although
- July 13, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

US And NATO Focus On China And Arctic Threats

FRIDAY PDB – NATO allies call China a ‘decisive enabler’ of Russia’s war
- July 12, 2024

Foreign Affairs

0 views
American Liberty News

Report: Biden Skipped Crucial Meeting Because Of Early Bedtime

The Wall Street Journal reported Wednesday that President Joe Biden declined an
- July 10, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

The French Revolution: Part Deux

French Prime Minister Gabriel Attal announced his resignation following the victory of
- July 10, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Columbia University Addresses Antisemitic Texts From Administrators

Columbia University has finally addressed the issue surrounding the three deans who
- July 10, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

BBC Host Calls For Trump’s Assassination, Blames Critics For Lack Of Humor

BBC presenter David Aaronovitch has come under fire for urging President Biden
- July 9, 2024

Business & economics

0 views
American Liberty News
0 views
American Liberty News

Congress Investigating Whether Woke Activists Broke Federal Tax Law With ESG Investment Schemes

A key congressional committee is now investigating whether a liberal activist scheme to
- June 25, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Elizabeth Warren For Fairness?

Today, U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren, also known as the fake Indian, will speak
- June 17, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Citizens Sue City Over Scheme To Pay Race Reparations

A group of Evanston, Illinois, residents are suing their city government over a
- June 7, 2024

heath & science

0 views
American Liberty News

Award-Winning Actress Shelley Duvall Passes Away At 75

Award-winning actress Shelley Duvall has died. The longtime movie star and producer known
- July 11, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Former Oklahoma Senator Jim Inhofe Dead At 89

Former Oklahoma Senator Jim Inhofe, a towering figure in conservative politics, passed away
- July 10, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Renowned Neurologist’s Frequent White House Visits Raise Alarms

Much of the country believes that Joe Biden does not have the mental
- July 10, 2024
0 views
American Liberty News

Joe Biden Is The Real ‘Cheap Fake’ – Entire Presidency A Lie

ANALYSIS – Cheap fake president. Despite the outrageous spin and deception, by the
- July 9, 2024

American Liberty Arms

Elderly Oakland Homeowner Shoots Burglar, Goes To Jail

The Oakland Police Department has jailed a 77-year-old homeowner on suspicion of murder. The arrest

Vending Machines For Ammo!

Grocery stores in Alabama and Oklahoma have adopted AI-powered ammo vending machines from American Rounds,

Alec Baldwin Manslaughter Trial Begins

The trial for actor Alec Baldwin for the fatal shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on

Olympic Shooting Grandma Shoots Intruder While Handcuffed to Chair

Bodycam footage shows the aftermath of an Idaho home invasion that didn’t end well for

At American Liberty News, we eschew the mainstream media’s tightly controlled narrative to provide our readers with real news, real insights, and the means to take action. We seek out insightful coverage – and partner with knowledgeable and experienced people and organizations to bring you the information and insight our readers demand.

 

We humbly seek to provide the tools and information necessary for our readers to decide for themselves what is true and what is right.

American Liberty News ©2022

Evolution Digital Media  |   1900 Reston Metro Plz  |  Suite 600  |  Reston, VA 20190