Prosecutors in the murder trial of Karmelo Anthony reportedly dismissed several potential jurors after they expressed hesitation about convicting the teenager if it could send him to prison for life, despite the brutality of his crime.
Anthony is charged in the fatal stabbing of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during a track meet in Frisco, Texas. He has claimed he acted in self-defense following an altercation over seating inside a team tent.
During jury selection, prosecutors questioned prospective jurors about whether Anthony’s age, race or resemblance to their own children would affect their ability to weigh the evidence and consider a guilty verdict.
Several potential jurors reportedly said Anthony “looks like a child” and indicated they were uncomfortable with the possibility of sending someone so young to prison for life.
“I don’t think I can make a decision about somebody so young,” one potential juror reportedly told Assistant District Attorney Dewey Mitchell. “One mistake, one argument, one conflict, you can’t say he’s a bad person.”
Mitchell reminded the jury pool that no one would be “in trouble” for honestly stating their views during the selection process.
Prosecutors also asked potential jurors how they felt about “finding an African American male guilty of murder,” according to reports.
“I don’t know if I feel right putting a brother in jail,” one prospective juror reportedly said.
The remarks highlight one of the central challenges facing prosecutors as they seek to seat a jury in a case that has drawn national attention and intense emotional reactions.
Attorneys are expected to finalize jury selection from a pool of roughly 250 candidates.
Anthony is accused of stabbing Metcalf the chest after a confrontation during the track meet. According to an arrest report obtained by Fox News, Metcalf had told Anthony to leave the Memorial team’s tent before the dispute escalated.
A witness reportedly told police that Anthony grabbed his bag, opened it, reached inside and said, “Touch me and see what happens.”
The report says Metcalf then stood up and pushed Anthony in an attempt to get him out of the tent. Moments later, the witness told investigators, Anthony allegedly pulled a knife from the bag and stabbed Metcalf.
Anthony reportedly fled after the stabbing but later asked if what he did could be considered self-defense.
“I was protecting myself,” Anthony allegedly said. “He put his hands on me.”
When confronted by officers, Anthony reportedly admitted to the stabbing.
“I’m not alleged, I did it,” he said, according to the report.
He also asked police whether Metcalf was “going to be OK.”
Metcalf died in the arms of his twin brother, Hunter, who later described the horrifying final moments during an appearance on The Will Cain Show.
“I whipped my head around, and then all of a sudden I see him running down the bleachers just grabbing his chest,” Hunter said.
“I put my hand on there, tried to make the bleeding stop, and I grabbed his head, and I looked in his eyes,” he continued. “I just saw his soul leave, and it took my soul, too.”
The case has become a flashpoint in debates over self-defense, youth crime, race and the criminal justice system. Prosecutors are expected to argue that Anthony escalated the confrontation by introducing a deadly weapon into what began as a seating dispute.
The defense is expected to argue that Anthony feared for his safety after being physically confronted and pushed.
Many following the case have raised questions about why the footage from the facility has yet to be released to the public.
The jury selection controversy suggests attorneys are closely scrutinizing whether potential jurors can separate sympathy, identity and emotion from the legal questions at the center of the trial.
For prosecutors, the challenge is finding jurors willing to consider the full consequences of a murder conviction despite Anthony’s immutable characteristics.
The trial is expected to proceed once a final jury is seated.
READ NEXT: Karmelo Anthony Granted Indigent Status, Public Defender Despite Raising Over Half A Million
